Research Brief · June 13, 2024

Probiotics During and After Antibiotics: What the Research Shows

Decent evidence for one narrow job. Weak evidence for the job on the label.

It’s close to standard advice now: if you’re prescribed an antibiotic, pick up a probiotic too. Pharmacists suggest it, friends swear by it, and product labels promise to “replenish good bacteria.” Part of that advice rests on decent evidence. Part of it runs ahead of the evidence, and one small study suggests the “replenish” claim may have things backwards.

This brief separates the two questions that usually get blended together: whether probiotics reduce digestive side effects during a course of antibiotics, and whether they help your gut microbiome recover after one.

Why antibiotics upset the gut

Antibiotics can’t tell the bacteria causing an infection from the trillions living in your colon. A course typically lowers the diversity of the gut microbiome for a while, which changes how carbohydrates and bile acids are processed and can leave room for less friendly organisms to expand.

The most common result is antibiotic-associated diarrhea. Estimates vary, but roughly 5-30% of people taking antibiotics experience it. Risk is higher with broad-spectrum drugs, longer courses, older age, and hospital stays. Most cases are mild and resolve on their own after the course ends. A small fraction involve Clostridioides difficile (C. diff), which can be serious and needs medical treatment.

What trials show for antibiotic-associated diarrhea

This is the strongest part of the evidence. Several large reviews have pooled dozens of randomized trials, and they generally find fewer cases of diarrhea in people given probiotics alongside their antibiotics than in people given a placebo or nothing. The relative reduction lands somewhere between a third and a half, depending on the review.

The pediatric data is the easiest to picture. In pooled trials of children, about 8% of those given probiotics developed diarrhea compared with about 19% of those who weren’t, which works out to roughly one child spared for every nine treated. Higher doses, at or above 5 billion CFU per day, performed better than lower ones.

These numbers come with several caveats:

  • The trials are very uneven. They used different strains, doses, antibiotics, and definitions of diarrhea, and many were small. Reviewers consistently flag this.
  • Some large, well-run trials found nothing. One UK trial of nearly 3,000 older hospital patients tested a multi-strain lactobacillus and bifidobacterium product and found no reduction in antibiotic-associated diarrhea or C. diff.
  • Benefit depends on baseline risk. If your chance of diarrhea on a short course of a narrow-spectrum antibiotic is already low, there isn’t much for a probiotic to improve.

So the fair summary is that specific probiotics, at adequate doses, probably lower the odds of diarrhea during antibiotics for many people. A generic “probiotic” from the shelf may not.

Strain matters

Probiotics are not interchangeable. Two have the most consistent track record in this setting:

  • Lactobacillus rhamnosus GG (LGG). The most studied bacterial strain, particularly in children. Trials commonly used 10-20 billion CFU per day.
  • Saccharomyces boulardii. A yeast, not a bacterium, which means antibacterial drugs don’t kill it. Trials commonly used 250-500 mg (about 5-10 billion CFU) once or twice daily. Antifungal medications will inactivate it.

Multi-strain blends are harder to judge. A few specific combinations have positive hospital trials behind them, and others have come up empty. A label reading “50 billion CFU, 12 strains” tells you nothing about whether that particular mix has ever been tested with antibiotics. Our guide to probiotic strains explains how to read strain designations, and the probiotics profile covers general dosing and quality.

C. diff: the evidence is contested

Pooled analyses suggest fewer cases of C. diff-associated diarrhea in people given probiotics, but the effect is concentrated in studies where the baseline risk was unusually high (above about 5%). In lower-risk settings, which describes most outpatient prescriptions, a benefit isn’t clear.

Professional gastroenterology groups have read the same data differently. One has issued a conditional, low-certainty suggestion that specific strains may be used by people taking antibiotics. Another recommends against using probiotics for this purpose. When guideline panels disagree like that, the evidence is not strong enough to rely on.

Probiotics do not treat C. diff or any other infection. Seek medical care if you develop watery diarrhea three or more times a day lasting more than two days, fever, significant abdominal pain, or blood in the stool, either during a course of antibiotics or in the weeks afterward.

The “restore your microbiome” claim

This is the claim printed on most labels, and it has the weakest support.

In most healthy adults, the gut microbiome recovers largely on its own over a few weeks to a couple of months after a short antibiotic course, though some species may take longer to return. The question is whether a probiotic speeds that up.

One small but carefully done human study tested this directly. After a week of broad-spectrum antibiotics, volunteers who took a multi-strain probiotic saw their original microbiome return more slowly, over months, than volunteers who took nothing. A third group, given back a sample of their own pre-antibiotic gut bacteria, recovered within days. The study was small and tested a single product, so it isn’t the final word. It does undercut the assumption that swallowing a handful of commercial strains “reseeds” a community of hundreds of native species.

That fits with what is known more generally: most probiotic strains pass through and don’t take up permanent residence. A realistic goal for a probiotic is fewer loose stools during the course. Rebuilding your gut ecosystem afterward is something the supplement hasn’t been shown to do.

What plausibly supports recovery is feeding the microbes you already have, which means a varied diet with plenty of fiber-rich plants. Fermented foods are a reasonable addition if you enjoy them; see fermented foods vs. probiotic supplements. Increase fiber gradually if your gut is still unsettled.

How to use a probiotic with antibiotics

If you and your clinician decide a probiotic makes sense, the trial protocols point to a few practical rules:

  1. Start early. Begin within the first day or two of the antibiotic course. Starting after diarrhea appears has less support.
  2. Space the doses. Take bacterial probiotics at least 2 hours before or after each antibiotic dose so the drug doesn’t simply kill them. S. boulardii doesn’t need spacing from antibacterial drugs.
  3. Use a studied dose. 5-40 billion CFU per day of a strain with evidence in this setting. Going far above that hasn’t been shown to work better.
  4. Continue briefly afterward. Many trials continued for about 1-2 weeks after the antibiotic ended. There’s no evidence favoring months of use for this purpose.
  5. Check the label. Look for a full strain designation, a CFU count guaranteed through the expiration date, storage instructions, and third-party testing.

Safety and who should not self-prescribe

For healthy adults and children, the studied probiotics are well tolerated. Gas and bloating in the first few days are the usual complaints.

The exceptions are important. Rare bloodstream infections caused by probiotic organisms have been reported, almost entirely in vulnerable groups:

  • People who are severely immunocompromised (for example during chemotherapy or after a transplant)
  • People who are critically ill or have a central venous catheter
  • Premature infants, for whom regulators have issued specific warnings

Anyone in these groups should use probiotics only on medical advice. If you are pregnant or nursing, or choosing a product for a child, ask your clinician or pediatrician about the strain and dose first.

A few other cautions apply during a course of antibiotics:

  • Don’t stop or skip your antibiotic because of mild diarrhea without talking to the prescriber, and never use a probiotic in place of one.
  • Watch your other supplements. Calcium, iron, magnesium, and zinc can bind certain antibiotics (notably tetracyclines and fluoroquinolones) and reduce their absorption. These usually need to be separated by several hours; your pharmacist can give exact timing. Our antibiotics and supplements interaction guide has the details.

Bottom line

Taking a well-studied probiotic such as LGG or S. boulardii alongside antibiotics, at 5-40 billion CFU per day, has reasonable evidence for lowering the chance of antibiotic-associated diarrhea, though results vary and some large trials found no benefit. The evidence for C. diff is contested, and the claim that probiotics rebuild your microbiome afterward isn’t supported and may be backwards. For most healthy people it’s a low-risk, optional add-on for the length of the course and a week or two beyond. People with weakened immune systems, serious illness, or central lines should not take one without their care team’s approval.

This article is educational and not medical advice. Consult a healthcare provider before starting any supplement, especially if you are pregnant, nursing, taking medication, or managing a health condition.